“Navy blue eyeliner makes the whites of your eyes look whiter and therefore more alert,” says Shayne. And it complements every eye color and skin tone so try Maybelline Define-A-Line Eyeliner in Navy Blue ($4.49). Then curl your lashes to open up your eyes and swipe on a lengthening and thickening black mascara like CoverGirl Professional All In One Curved Mascara ($4.79).