Frasier’s excitement about his son’s arrival is diminished when Frederick shows up in shocking goth attire—donning all black, chains and dark makeup. Even worse, his goth girlfriend, Andi, is in town and he only wants to hang out with her. Daphne and Martin try to console Frasier by recalling their own rebellious stages. However, Niles is ashamed when he realizes he was a “goody two-shoes” his whole life; he sets out to sow his wild oats.

Roz hooks Niles up with a pot-laced brownie made by her neighbor. Unbeknownst to him, Martin innocently intercepts the brownie, polishes it off and orders another to replace it before Niles returns. Later, Niles brags to Frasier about his “high”, with only a nibble missing from the brownie. Moments later, Martin comes home, completely stoned. He laughs uncontrollably and talks nonsense. Niles believes that Martin’s outrageous behavior is a figment of his own hallucination. Frasier realizes the mix up when Martin refrigerates his pants and dips potato chips in pudding.

When Frasier forbids Frederick from spending the weekend with Andi, Frederick leaves in a huff. He later returns home, after getting dumped, and turns to Frasier for advice.