While discussing the upcoming SeaBeas radio awards at Cafe Nervosa, Frasier, Roz and Bulldog are witnesses to a crime: an armed robber enters the coffee shop and demands money. Bulldog uses the very pregnant Roz to shield himself from harm, but ends up spilling his hot coffee on the man, who drops the gun and runs out.

Hailed as a hero for foiling the robbery, Bulldog's head swells when Roz announces on the air that Bulldog will receive special recognition at the SeaBeas awards for his "brave" exploits. Aghast that Bulldog is being honored when he actually put Roz's life in danger, Frasier tries to talk some sense into Bulldog, who refuses to come clean about the matter.

At the SeaBeas awards, Frasier tries to shame Bulldog into telling the truth by bringing back his boyhood priest and other role models, and having them talk about the importance of honesty. Bulldog winds up admitting that the whole coffee shop incident was an accident and that he doesn't deserve the award. To Frasier's chagrin, this heartfelt confession only makes the audience praise Bulldog's honesty even more!