Frasier’s torn between two lovers: Lana, the lusty bombshell, or Claire, who’s “perfect” for him.

During a family vacation in the Caribbean, everybody thinks Claire is the ideal mate for Frasier, but he’s still smitten with Lana. After polling everyone from his father and brother to total strangers, Frasier decides to stay with Claire – until Lana invites him to her son Kirby’s graduation party. Later, while retrieving his lost luggage at the airport, Frasier runs into a fan of his show, who’s also having trouble choosing between his girlfriend and his ex-wife. With Frasier’s help, the man decides to give his marriage another try.

Meanwhile, Niles retires his bearded “Island Niles” persona after baring it all at a local spot Roz mistakenly thought was a nude beach. Having endeared herself to Frasier’s inner circle, Claire isn’t the only one who’s furious when Frasier dumps her. Martin, Daphne and Niles are upset about the split, as well.

Now free to pursue Lana, Frasier heads over to Kirby’s graduation party, along with Roz, who reluctantly served as Kirby’s prom date. Before Frasier has a chance to tell Lana he wants to date her, he sees a familiar face among Kirby’s guests: it’s the guy from the airport. But he’s not just any party crasher – he’s Lana’s ex-husband, who’s come to reconcile with her.